It's an opportunity to get a great player on the cheap, so 'it could be' good business. All players are a gamble. We at least know him. We paid buttons for him, and got buttons back for him. Had we never had him in the side, £5m would be a good price, so it's irrelevant that he was once our player. What 'is' irrelevant is that he is for sale, and we have a decision to make. Yes, he's had injuries, but you don't get much for your money these days. At the moment, it's a pointless discussion though, as he might go elsewhere.