I'd say Zaha is a much better all round player than Redmond but Zaha has got at least a seasons more experience. Redmond is potential and at £2-3m he's well worth investing in - if it doesn't work-out then he'll still prob be worth that in 5yrs time but if it does work-out, well... I must say I wasn't overly impressed with him last season but he's young and seems to have the attributes required to be a very good player. If Roberto rates him then that's good enough for me!