All good on the notifications... seemed to only get one. I guess my perception of “best player” has more to do with talent and ability than importance to our team. Being the club that we are, sometimes a bit soft and always having to fight for points against the top 6, I can see a case being made for a healthy McCarthy being our most important player and that we miss his presence more than we might miss any other player in our current squad.
That said, he hasn’t put together a healthy season where he played more than 28 games since his first season here, and on ability alone, I don’t think he cracks the top 5. It’s the work rate and attitude that propel him into the conversation for importance, but I still don’t see how he can be considered the best we have.